Ten years after the UK entered into a hurried referendum that polarised the country and triggered turmoil, a caution emerges from beyond the Irish Sea: it might repeat.
Policymakers and electorate drifted into Brexit and the identical could occur with a referendum on a united Ireland, initiating disturbances for which nobody is ready.
That represents the warning from two respected commentators from both sides of the Irish border who have teamed up to examine the advantages and disadvantages of Northern Ireland exiting the UK to create a fresh nation with the Republic of Ireland.
Political Establishments Unprepared
Fintan O’Toole and The Northern Ireland editor, have determined that the administrative systems in Ireland and Britain are woefully unprepared for a possibly tense and seismic public vote.
"The crucial insight of Brexit hasn't been learned, which is that developments can emerge unexpectedly and can gain traction rapidly," the commentator stated. "In my opinion that the governmental framework of our islands remains extremely volatile."
New Title Aims to Provoke Discussion
The pair have examined the political, financial and cultural arguments for any constitutional change in a book, The Case For and Against Unification, issued by the Dublin-based Royal Irish Academy.
They aim to stir debate on the issue with a series of lectures that will take them to Westminster in the coming weeks.
"What troubles everyone, or must worry everybody, is the Brexit vote of 2016," said O’Toole.
"We do not want a national vote on a binary, vague proposition whose consequences have remained undefined because then you land with an extraordinarily divided society where those defeated are unable to accept losing and the victorious side lack clarity quite what it is that they have gained."
Legal Framework
Under the peace accord, the Northern Ireland government minister should call a referendum on Irish unification if it appears likely that a majority would approve.
Sinn Féin and other pro-unification groups claim this point is approaching, and a non-profit named Ireland’s Future has garnered backing, but both governments and unionists play down the likelihood, making it uncertain when or if there might be a national vote.
Lack of Substantive Discussion
Political rhetoric for and against unity has hidden the lack of substantive discussion, stated the journalist.
"People tend to be supportive or opposed the notion but the actual thinking which may surpass that to achieve it is mostly absent. Much has occurred in universities but hardly any elected officials or campaigners are willing to participate even with the fundamentals. For instance, what type of nation should be desired? Unitary? Decentralised?"
Publication's Method
In the volume, no writer advocates unification or the status quo. Each writes two articles that aim for impartiality in laying out the case for a unified Ireland and the argument against, marshalling economic and social statistics, historical precedents and structural examples.
Arguments encompass identity markers, taxes, health services, elderly benefits, national debt responsibilities and the risk of loyalist violence. The goal is to inform and provoke dialogue.
"There is significant curiosity in the subject but there has not yet occurred a debate," commented O’Toole. "Discussion implies an acknowledgement of the concept that there might be good arguments on each side."
Simultaneous Plebiscites
A referendum in Northern Ireland would additionally cause one in the republic, where the electorate say they prefer unification but oppose paying higher taxes or implementing a new flag to acknowledge pro-UK communities' British identity.
"Policymakers in Ireland should determine what the offer from Irish nationalism is beyond just stating: 'We seek a unified Ireland and we love you'," said the commentator.
Possibility of Public Vote
The journalist thinks a referendum in his generation is possible and that it might occur unexpectedly. "There might be just a mad or a bad or a feckless official who states: 'Let's just do this and settle the matter.'"
Each of the pro-unification advocates and pro-UK supporters have credible, justified perspectives, he commented. "Somebody will succeed in this matter and the other side will in the end not succeed but all factions has possesses something to acquire from the other's positions."
Request for Wider Debate
Westminster must join the debate, urged the analyst. "This involves the United Kingdom. It's a UK matter as much as it is an Irish matter."